[s2e18] Girl Meets World: Of Terror 2 -

: Reviewers appreciated the episode's stylistic risks, specifically the claymation sequence where Riley and Maya experience each other's minds.

: Despite the writing, lead actresses Rowan Blanchard and Sabrina Carpenter were praised for their energy during the "Hot Feet" song-and-dance numbers. [S2E18] Girl Meets World: Of Terror 2

: Unlike the first Halloween special, this episode was seen as "solid filler" that failed to advance the season's character arcs. [S2E18] Girl Meets World: Of Terror 2

: The introduction of Brittany Ross as the 1920s ghost haunting Riley’s bay window was one of the better-received elements. Her story provided a sweet, albeit "cheesy," exploration of Riley and Maya's friendship. [S2E18] Girl Meets World: Of Terror 2

Critics and fans shared their frustration with the episode's gimmicky tone and disjointed plot: