Reviews of the track generally fall into two categories: praise for its polished pop production and criticism for its "cheesy" nature.
It held the record for the most weeks spent on the Adult Contemporary chart (124 weeks) for several years, narrowly beating out Savage Garden's own "Truly Madly Deeply". Shared Perspectives Savage Garden I Knew I Loved You MP3 Download
: The song was written specifically because the band's record label wanted a big follow-up ballad to "Truly Madly Deeply". It reportedly took only 15 minutes to write. Reviews of the track generally fall into two
: Critics from Billboard described the song as "absolutely enchanting" and "one of the most beautiful songs of 1999," praising Darren Hayes' confident, effortless vocal performance. Others, like editors at AllMusic, noted it as "hooky and memorable". It reportedly took only 15 minutes to write
“Whenever i hear this song i just feel like being in love. I like it 10/10 im cheesy that way.” Reddit · r/DarrenHayes · 1 year ago Kirsten Dunst - Savage Garden: I Knew I Loved You - IMDb
: Community reviews on sites like Rate Your Music can be more polarized, with some users calling it a "shitty boy band song" and a "cheesefest," while others defend its status as a timeless wedding classic. Song Composition & Background