The general consensus is that the game is a "friendship-ending" masterclass in party game design.
“me and my friends hate each other now but its worth it” Steam
: Critics at God is a Geek and Xbox Tavern highlight its "hilarious slapstick" and "sadistic creativity," making it a staple for holiday gatherings and game nights.
“The style of Ultimate Chicken Horse is great and when it all comes together, it is a special brand of silly party gaming.” Nintendo World Report · 7 years ago
: Several reviews from Video Chums mention that the menu and hub system can be inconsistent and confusing to navigate.
“This is the perfect party game that is not about winning, but about seeing your friends lose.” Metacritic
: Most critics, including those at Nintendo World Report, emphasize that the "magic evaporates" when playing alone. It is strictly designed as a multiplayer experience.